Commentary on Legislative Changes and Development
New FSCA amendments to Conduct Standard to enhance pension fund transparency and governance
The Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) has introduced comprehensive amendments to the FSRA Conduct Standard 1 of 2019 under the Pension Funds Act (PFA), marking a significant step toward enhancing the transparency, accountability and governance of pension fund administrators in South Africa. The 2024 amendments reflect the FSCA’s commitment to ...
Read More
Relevant Rulings
Tribunal overturns ruling against Futurum Financial Group in life cover dispute; compliance lessons
The Financial Services Tribunal ('the Tribunal') recently overturned a decision by the Ombud for Financial Services Providers, which had required Futurum Financial Group (Pty) Ltd to pay R800 000 in damages to Christopher Mark Shadwell, heir to the late Dr Tamryn Shadwell. The case arose after the cancellation of ...
Read More
C Nel and the Office of the FAIS Ombud and Barton Insurance Brokers (broker negligence in conveying tracker requirement)
Financial Services Tribunal ('FST' or 'the Tribunal')
The following matter was handed down by the FST on 5 November 2024:
- Nel v Office of the FAIS Ombud and Barton Insurance Brokers (Pty) Ltd – (case number: FAB37/2024)
Fast facts
Insurance claim for stolen Fortuner – Secondary tracking device requirement ...
Read More
Mziwamadoda Ignatious Mkhuma v FSCA (reconsideration application dismissed in FSCA honesty and integrity case)
In a recent case before the Financial Services Tribunal, applicant Mziwamadoda Ignatious Mkhuma sought reconsideration of the Financial Sector Conduct Authority's (FSCA) decision to deny a Financial Services Provider (FSP) licence to Muzi Consulting Agency (Pty) Ltd, citing his failure to meet the fit and proper requirements of honesty ...
Read More
Simphiwe Innocent Mntungwa v Discovery Life/M Geyser (reconsideration appeal dismissed in Discovery Life debarment case)
Nelisiwe Carol Bhengu v Pension Funds Adjudicator and others (reconsideration application – death benefit)
Enforcement News
High-value penalties spotlight regulatory crackdown in South Africa’s financial sector
In 2024, the Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) and the Prudential Authority (PA) imposed striking administrative penalties, including ZAR 475 million, ZAR 210 million and ZAR 59 million, on various institutions and individuals for regulatory non-compliance, reports Webber Wentzel. Notably, the late Mr Jooste faced fines for insider trading, Sasfin ...
Read More
Auto & General's Knysna fire ad cleared by Advertising Regulatory Board
The Advertising Regulatory Board (ARB) has ruled that Auto & General’s (A&G) commercial depicting the 2017 Knysna fires does not breach the Code of Advertising Practice’s standards on offensive advertising, despite complaints from viewers who found it distressing.
The ad begins with footage of firefighters combating a massive blaze, alongside ...
Read More
Law firm’s R7.8m penalty for compliance failures upheld by FIC appeal board
The Financial Intelligence Centre (FIC) appeal board recently dismissed an appeal from Kunene Ramapala Incorporated, a law firm penalised R7.8 million for failing to meet compliance standards under the FIC Act. Following an inspection in June 2023, the FIC found that the firm had not implemented a risk management ...
Read More
News from the Regulators
New FSCA fee determination for 2024: Overview for financial sector professionals
The Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) has issued General Notice 1 of 2024, establishing updated fees for various applications, exemptions and services across South Africa’s financial sector. Effective from 1 October 2024, these fees apply to entities regulated under significant financial legislation, including the Collective Investment Schemes Control Act, Financial ...
Read More
Regulator warns about trading company's unrealistic returns
Legalbrief Today
The Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) has issued a warning about FXnonstop (Pty) Ltd that is offering investors returns of 40% per week, reports The Citizen. The company offers trading software for investors and says its ‘cutting-edge software’ will ‘unlock the power of seamless trading’. According to the ...
Read More
Basel III regulations shape the future of non-bank financial institutions and fintech in South Africa
As Basel III regulations reshape the South African financial landscape, a new study reveals significant implications for non-bank financial institutions (NBFIs) and fintech platforms, according to a report published on the SARB website. The findings highlight both the challenges and opportunities that arise as traditional banks face stricter capital and ...
Read More
FSCA signals possible revival of auto-enrolment for retirement savings in South Africa
FSCA update on the licence of Banxso (Pty) Ltd
Compliance Focus
FSCA and Prudential Authority set new standards for insurer cybersecurity and outsourcing compliance
The Financial Sector Conduct Authority (FSCA) and the Prudential Authority (PA) have announced the implementation dates for two new regulatory standards: Joint Standard 1 of 2024 (Outsourcing by Insurers), effective from 1 December 2024, and Joint Standard 2 of 2024 (Cybersecurity and Cyber Resilience Requirements), effective 1 June 2025. These ...
Read More
The evolving privacy risk landscape: Managing compliance in a data-driven world
As new technologies advance and global regulations evolve, the privacy risk landscape is reshaping, presenting significant challenges for organisations aiming to stay compliant and protect sensitive data, reports Marsh in a new analysis. Although many companies have proactively addressed privacy risks, the pace of regulatory change and the adoption of ...
Read More
Anti-Money Laundering
South Africa’s progress in reversing its FATF greylisting
South African authorities are actively addressing the remaining six action items outlined by the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) to exit the grey list, notes a report by Clyde & Co on the Lexology site. National Treasury recently announced that South Africa has largely or fully addressed 16 of the ...
Read More
£16m (R363 520 000) fine for Metro Bank as FCA uncovers years of AML monitoring failures
The UK's Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) has imposed a £16 million fine on Metro Bank for significant anti-money laundering (AML) failures related to inadequate monitoring systems. Between June 2016 and December 2020, Metro Bank’s systems failed to properly oversee over 60 million transactions valued at more than £51 billion ...
Read More
FATF shifts greylisting focus to developed nations, eases compliance for least developed countries
The Financial Action Task Force (FATF) has revised its greylisting criteria, now focusing on developed countries with sophisticated financial systems capable of impacting the global financial landscape, reports African Law & Business. Announced on 17 October 2024, the change seeks to adjust the compliance burden towards high-income countries, reducing the ...
Read More
FATF publishes Money Laundering National Risk Assessment Guidance
Making sense of beneficial ownership thresholds: Distinguishing the FIC Act from the Companies Act
Crypto Assets
Two convicted in £1.5m UK crypto investment fraud
Two individuals, Raymondip Bedi and Patrick Mavanga, have been convicted in the UK for defrauding over 65 investors out of £1.5 million in a fake cryptocurrency investment scheme, reports Investment International. Between 2017 and 2019, Bedi and Mavanga lured consumers through cold calls and a sophisticated website, promising high ...
Read More
Trump’s financial deregulation plans expected to push crypto mainstream in the US
Cryptocurrencies are set to enter the mainstream in the United States as former President Trump’s deregulation agenda gains momentum, according to GlobalData’s latest insights. Banking analyst Blandina Hanna Szalay noted that Trump’s vision to establish the US as a 'crypto capital' could significantly increase crypto ownership, reaching previously untapped ...
Read More
MiCA deadline nears: Crypto firms face compliance challenges as EU regulation takes shape
With the Markets in Crypto-Assets (MiCA) regulation deadline fast approaching, many firms across Europe are racing to align with the new standards, reports Electronic Payments International. MiCA’s requirements encompass broad obligations to monitor, detect and prevent market abuse within the crypto market, posing unique challenges for compliance, particularly for firms ...
Read More
Data Protection
Court rules buyer must pay debt after falling victim to cyber scam; full judgment in Gripper & Company v Ganedhi Trading Enterprise
A company that fell victim to a cyber scam must now settle its debt to a supplier it mistakenly thought it had paid electronically, reports Pretoria News. In today’s climate, where scams are increasingly prevalent, it is the payer's responsibility to verify the accuracy of bank account details for ...
Read More
Global privacy regulators call for stronger anti-scraping measures and compliance with AI data protection laws
On 28 October 2024, sixteen international regulators from the Global Privacy Assembly’s International Enforcement Cooperation Working Group (IWEG) issued a Concluding Statement addressing the protection of personal data against unauthorised scraping, according to a report on the Lexology site. This follows the Initial Statement from August 2023, where regulators began ...
Read More
South Africa ranked 32nd in cyber security preparedness as data breaches surge
South Africa currently ranks 32nd out of 54 countries in terms of cyber security preparedness, as revealed by a recent study from Psono, an open-source password manager. This ranking highlights the nation’s vulnerability in handling data security challenges, with an overall composite score of 19.1, placing it below the ...
Read More
Environmental, Social & Governance
Treasury releases carbon tax phase two proposal
Legalbrief Today
The Treasury has released its discussion paper on phase two of SA’s carbon tax design, proposing the adjustments that will be implemented in 2026–35. A Business Day report says while this provides businesses with clarity on effective carbon tax rates they may face, there are concerns the proposed ...
Read More
SEC fines Invesco $17.5m (ZAR 337 087 100) for misleading ESG claims on assets under management
The US Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) has charged Invesco Advisers, Inc with making misleading claims about the integration of environmental, social and governance (ESG) factors in its investment decisions. The SEC’s findings reveal that between 2020 and 2022, Invesco reported that 70–94% of its assets under management were 'ESG ...
Read More
Local News
MTI Ponzi mastermind wanted dead or alive
Legalbrief Today
MTI CEO Johann Steynberg was reported to have died in Goiânia, Brazil, in April 2024 by Brazilian media, three-and-a-half years after he fled to the country following the implosion of one of the world’s biggest cryptocurrency scams. However, a visit by Moneyweb last month to the cemetery where ...
Read More
President challenges BHF’s NHI Act case on jurisdiction grounds
President Cyril Ramaphosa’s legal team has attacked the Board of Healthcare Funders’ (BHF) challenge to the National Health Insurance (NHI) Act on technical grounds, asserting that the medical scheme industry association brought its case before the wrong court. According to a Business Day report, the Act faces three separate legal ...
Read More
Western Cape High Court lifts R100m preservation order against Banxso
The Western Cape High Court has taken less than a day to lift a preservation order against R100m in bank accounts linked to controversial brokerage Banxso. Acting Judge Susan van Zyl issued the ruling, without reasons, on Friday, according to Fin24. On Thursday afternoon, Banxso had argued in an urgent ...
Read More
Navigating the threats of corruption and organised crime for South African businesses
BHI Trust Ponzi scheme victims left in limbo amidst case closures and legal uncertainties
FSCA warns against pyramid scheme Tiger Agriculture as new clones emerge
International News
Former Australian investment manager Brett Trevillian sentenced to three years for forging investor reports
Brett Paul Trevillian, former director of Metal Alpha Pty Ltd and investment manager at AlphaThorn Pty Ltd, has been sentenced to three years in prison by the Sydney District Court after pleading guilty to forging investment performance reports for investors. Trevillian was found to have falsified reports between April and ...
Read More
UK's FCA bans and fines insurance broker Leigh Mackey £1.1m (R26m) for misuse of funds and regulatory deception
The UK's FCA has imposed a lifetime ban and a £1 102 879 fine on Leigh Mackey, barring him from the financial services sector for misusing funds owed to insurers and misleading regulators. As the sole director of Inspire Insurance Services Ltd, an insurance broker for the construction industry ...
Read More
German and Cypriot authorities dismantle €10m (R188.5m) fake investment scam targeting German investors
German and Cypriot authorities, with assistance from Eurojust and Europol, have dismantled 13 fake investment platforms that defrauded German investors of approximately €10 million, reports International Adviser. A coordinated cross-border operation on 4 November 2024 led to the arrest of four suspects in Cyprus, where the fraudulent activities were run ...
Read More
Technology to augment, not replace, financial advisers
ASIC outlines 2025 enforcement priorities, tackling cost-of-living pressures
Working Smart
Financial advice as an intangible service
By Lee Rossini
Giving financial advice is an intangible service – it doesn’t involve a physical product that clients can see, touch or easily quantify. Instead, it consists of expertise, trust, planning and strategic insights tailored to meet clients’ financial goals. This makes financial advice complex to package, market and ...
Read More
General
The growing threat of AI deep fake scams
The rapid rise of Artificial Intelligence (AI) has revolutionised industries worldwide, enabling advancements that enhance productivity and profitability, reports CMS Law. Yet, AI’s power to simulate human problem-solving also offers advantages to those with malicious intent, notably in the form of 'deep fake' technologies. For the insurance sector, which increasingly ...
Read More
Former SAA director Yakhe Kwinana fails to settle R6.7m Saica fine 19 months on
Yakhe Kwinana, the former director of South African Airways (SAA), has yet to pay the R6.7 million penalty imposed by the South African Institute of Chartered Accountants (Saica) nearly 19 months ago, City Press reports. Kwinana, known for her controversial remarks at the State Capture Commission, was closely linked ...
Read More